Curseforge vs Modrinth - Which one to choose?

Table of Contents

  • 1. key similarities between CurseForge and Modrinth 
  • 2. key differences between CurseForge and Modrinth 
  • 3. Advanced similarities between CurseForge and Modrinth 
  • 4. Use Case - Which one to choose

 

Curseforge vs Modrinth

What is CurseForge?

CurseForge is a content distribution platform for Minecraft and other games that hosts mods, modpacks, and addons. It offers a centralized hub for downloading, managing, and publishing game modifications, primarily integrated with the CurseForge Launcher and backed by Overwolf.

CurseForge's key features
  1. Mod Hosting – Central hub for downloading and publishing game mods.
  2. Modpack Support – Lets users create, share, and install full modpacks.
  3. CurseForge Launcher – Official launcher for easy mod and modpack management.
  4. One-Click Install – Installs mods with auto-handling of dependencies.
  5. Creator Rewards – Revenue-sharing program based on mod usage and ad views.
  6. Manual Moderation – All uploads are reviewed for safety and policy compliance.
  7. Multi-Version Support – Hosts mods compatible with multiple game versions.
  8. Update Notifications – Notifies users when installed mods get updated.
  9. Analytics for Creators – Provides mod download stats and user engagement data.
  10. API Access via Overwolf SDK – Supports limited third-party integrations using the Overwolf SDK.

 

What is Modrinth?

Modrinth is a modern, open-source platform for hosting and discovering Minecraft mods and modpacks, designed for speed, transparency, and developer-friendly workflows without ads or launcher lock-in. 

Key features of Modrinth
  1. Ad-Free Platform – Completely free of ads, ensuring a clean user experience.
  2. Open Source – Both frontend and backend are fully open for community contribution.
  3. Fast Approvals – Automated review system enables quick publishing (often within minutes).
  4. Clean UI – Minimalist and fast interface optimized for usability.
  5. CI/CD Integration – Supports GitHub Actions and webhooks for automatic mod publishing.
  6. Markdown Project Pages – Full Markdown support for customizable mod descriptions.
  7. Open API (REST & GraphQL) – No SDK lock-in; great for developers and launchers.
  8. Launcher Compatibility – Works with Prism, ATLauncher, MultiMC, and other third-party tools.
  9. Modpack System – Lightweight, JSON-based format independent of any specific launcher.

 

CurseForge is a well-established, Overwolf-backed platform offering a large mod library, ad-based monetization, and deep integration with its own launcher—ideal for legacy content and mass adoption.

Modrinth is a modern, open-source alternative focused on speed, privacy, and developer-friendliness—offering clean UI, fast uploads, open APIs, and compatibility with multiple launchers.

Bottom Line: CurseForge leads in size and legacy support; Modrinth excels in speed, transparency, and open development.

 

#1 key similarities between CurseForge and Modrinth 

  1. Minecraft Mod Hosting – Both platforms host mods and modpacks for Minecraft Java Edition.
  2. Support for Forge & Fabric – Both support the two most widely used modloaders: Forge, Fabric, NeoForge, and Quilt.
  3. Version Tracking – Allow mods to be published for specific Minecraft versions.
  4. Modpack Distribution – Enable users to create, upload, and share modpacks.
  5. Search & Filtering Tools – Provide search functionality with filters by modloader, version, and category.
  6. Download Statistics – Show download counts and version history per mod.
  7. Project Pages – Let developers present descriptions, screenshots, and links.
  8. User Accounts – Require account creation for uploading, commenting, and managing projects.
  9. Security Reviews – Implement safety checks to prevent malicious files from being distributed.

 

 

#2 Key Differences - between CurseForge vs Modrinth

 

2.1 Ownership

CurseForge: Operated by Overwolf, a commercial company focused on gaming mod ecosystems and monetization infrastructure.

Modrinth: Fully independent, maintained by a small developer team and backed by an open-source, community-driven philosophy.

 

CurseForge is commercially operated with monetization goals, while Modrinth prioritizes community ownership and open development.

 

2.2 Platform Scope

CurseForge: A multi-game platform, supporting modding for various titles like World of Warcraft, The Sims 4, Terraria, and others alongside Minecraft.

Modrinth: A Minecraft-exclusive platform, purpose-built for the Java Edition modding community.

 

CurseForge caters to a broader gaming mod audience, whereas Modrinth is specialized and focused purely on Minecraft Java Edition.

 

2.3 Monetization

CurseForge: Uses an ad-supported model where creators earn from download-based revenue through the CurseForge Rewards Program, tied to Overwolf’s platform.

Modrinth: Has no ads and empowers creators to receive income via direct donation links like Patreon, Ko-fi, or GitHub Sponsors.

 

CurseForge monetizes through platform ads and revenue-sharing, while Modrinth promotes transparent, creator-controlled donation support.



2.4 User Experience

CurseForge: Features a heavier interface, with integrated ads and dependencies on the Overwolf platform, which can affect responsiveness and navigation speed.

Modrinth: Offers a lightweight, clean, and ad-free interface, resulting in faster load times and smoother browsing, especially for developers and power users.

 

Modrinth delivers a faster, clutter-free experience, while CurseForge trades UI simplicity for monetization and launcher integration.

 

2.5 Approval Time

CurseForge: Uses a manual moderation process, where new mod uploads and updates are reviewed by staff—this can delay approval for several hours or even days.

Modrinth: Implements a semi-automated approval system, allowing most projects and updates to go live within minutes, with occasional manual checks for flagged content.

 

✅ Modrinth offers significantly faster publishing speed, making it ideal for rapid development cycles and quick updates.

 

2.6 Launcher Integration

CurseForge: Integrates tightly with the CurseForge Launcher, which runs on the Overwolf platform and is required for full functionality; third-party launcher support is limited and restricted by API access policies.

Modrinth: Designed with open compatibility, supporting popular third-party launchers like Prism Launcher, ATLauncher, MultiMC, and others—no vendor lock-in.

 

✅ Modrinth offers greater flexibility and independence with broad launcher support, while CurseForge prioritizes its own Overwolf-based ecosystem.

 

2.7 API Accessibility

CurseForge: Provides a restricted API that requires integration via the Overwolf SDK; usage is subject to terms and may limit access for independent launcher developers.

Modrinth: Offers fully open REST and GraphQL APIs with public documentation, allowing developers and launchers to integrate freely without platform constraints.

 

✅ Modrinth’s open API approach empowers developer freedom and integration, while CurseForge imposes tighter control through SDK dependencies.

 

 

2.8 Library Size

CurseForge: Hosts a larger and more established library of mods and modpacks, benefiting from its long-standing presence and early adoption in the Minecraft community.

Modrinth: Has a smaller but fast-growing collection, driven by modern tooling, developer-friendly workflows, and increasing community migration.

 

✅ CurseForge leads in volume due to legacy dominance, while Modrinth is catching up quickly with developer trust and modern infrastructure.

 

#3 Advanced Differences between CurseForge and Modrinth 

 

3.1 Developer Automation

CurseForge: Relies on manual uploads through the web interface or the CurseForge CLI, which is tightly coupled with the Overwolf platform and requires authentication via their ecosystem.

Modrinth: Enables automated CI/CD pipelines with built-in GitHub integration, webhook triggers, and support for tools like GitHub Actions for seamless publishing.

 

Modrinth streamlines developer workflows with automation and CI-friendly tools, while CurseForge remains more manual and Overwolf-dependent.

 

3.2 Download Infrastructure

CurseForge: Utilizes a CDN-based delivery system that can introduce throttling, particularly for non-launcher or anonymous downloads; performance may vary depending on the Overwolf client or geographic region.

Modrinth: Delivers content via fast, direct S3-hosted links with no download restrictions, offering consistent speed and reliability across all clients.

 

Modrinth offers faster, unrestricted downloads, while CurseForge's CDN setup may introduce variability and throttling outside its launcher.

 

3.3 Modpack Format

CurseForge: Uses a proprietary modpack format designed primarily for the CurseForge Launcher, with metadata and structure tightly coupled to Overwolf’s platform requirements—making third-party launcher support more complex.

Modrinth: Utilizes a modern, open JSON-based format that is launcher-agnostic, cleanly documented, and designed for easy integration with tools like Prism Launcher, ATLauncher, and MultiMC.

 

Modrinth promotes open, flexible modpack creation across any launcher, while CurseForge locks modpacks into its own ecosystem.

 

3.4 Markdown Support

CurseForge: Offers basic formatting for project pages using a restricted rich-text editor; lacks full Markdown syntax or advanced layout customization.

Modrinth: Provides complete Markdown support, allowing creators to structure project descriptions with headings, code blocks, tables, images, and links for enhanced clarity and presentation.

 

Modrinth enables fully customizable, developer-friendly project pages with Markdown, while CurseForge restricts formatting to simpler tools.

  

3.5 Legacy Modpack Support

CurseForge: Maintains strong compatibility with legacy modpacks, including popular formats from FTB (Feed The Beast) and Technic Launcher, making it ideal for users seeking older or long-standing modded Minecraft experiences.

Modrinth: Focuses on a cleaner, modern format that’s more modular and launcher-independent, but currently lacks full backward compatibility with legacy pack standards.

 

CurseForge is the go-to for legacy modpack compatibility, while Modrinth is optimized for modern, streamlined modpack development.

 

#4 Which One to Choose? —Use Case

  • Choose CurseForge if:
    ✔️ You want the largest mod library
    ✔️ You’re using old modpacks (like FTB or Technic)
    ✔️ You need monetization with minimal setup
    ✔️ You prefer using the CurseForge Launcher
  • Choose Modrinth if:
    ✔️ You want a lightweight, ad-free experience
    ✔️ You use Prism, MultiMC, or other third-party launchers
    ✔️ You prefer open-source, fast updates, and automation
    ✔️ You’re building modern modpacks or server setups

 

📌 Hope you found the content useful!

If you're looking for a reliable and high-performance Norway VPS or a fully customizable Norway Dedicated Server, we invite you to explore our hosting solutions.

🌐 Visit Us Today

 

FAQ 

🔹 What’s the main difference between CurseForge and Modrinth?

CurseForge is a multi-game, commercial platform by Overwolf, while Modrinth is Minecraft-only, open-source, and developer-first with no ads or tracking.

🔹 Which platform respects privacy more?

Modrinth collects no telemetry and has no ads. CurseForge, through Overwolf, includes user tracking for ad optimization and analytics.

🔹 How do both platforms handle license visibility?

Modrinth requires a clear open-source license per project. CurseForge does not enforce this strictly, making mod reuse terms less predictable.

🔹 Can I upload resource packs and data packs?

Yes. Both platforms support them, but Modrinth uses better categorization and cleaner UI for non-code assets.

🔹 Do both platforms support server modpacks?

Yes, both do. Modrinth’s modern `.mrpack` format is easier to deploy server-side, while CurseForge modpacks may require extraction or the CurseForge launcher.

🔹 Which platform is better for lightweight or minimal setups?

Modrinth, thanks to its open APIs, no Overwolf dependencies, and lightweight design, is ideal for minimal and scripted deployments.

🔹 Are changelogs and versioning better on one platform?

Modrinth offers structured changelogs, semantic versioning, and release channels. CurseForge supports changelogs but lacks advanced version tagging.

Comments are closed